Book Reviews, Find Your Next Read

The Squatters by Saba Brelvi: When doing the right thing comes at a cost

Saba Brelvi’s The Squatters explores the refugee experience, the limits of compassion, and the personal sacrifices involved in standing up for what is right.

The Squatters by Saba Brelvi is a novel about the complications of doing good when helping someone else means putting your own family, home, and security at risk. Set in an affluent neighborhood outside London, this debut explores the refugee experience through two families whose circumstances could hardly be more different. At its center is a question that becomes harder to answer as the story unfolds: How much should we be willing to sacrifice for people in need, and who gets to decide when that sacrifice has gone too far?

Dalia Waheed has built a comfortable life with her husband, Naseem, and their family in Surrey. Although she and her husband represent the kind of second-generation immigrant success story that should make them feel at home in their community, Dalia has never quite felt that she belongs. Through her volunteer work with Refugee Resettlement, she meets Hajira and Yusef, a young married couple seeking asylum in the United Kingdom. Hajira is pregnant, and the couple’s government-provided accommodations are far from the safe and comfortable environment they need as they prepare to welcome a child. Dalia feels an immediate connection to Hajira and becomes determined to help her find somewhere better to stay.

Unfortunately, Dalia’s good intentions do not seem to be accompanied by much common sense. She has enough life experience to understand that there are boundaries and precautions people should observe when helping strangers, especially when those strangers are in desperate circumstances. Organizations such as Refugee Resettlement have procedures for a reason. They are working with people who have experienced hardship, displacement, and trauma, and the people offering assistance need to protect themselves as well as those they are helping. Dalia seems to forget all of this. When she gives Hajira and Yusef her home address, I wanted to reach into the book and stop her. Even the nicest people can become dangerous when they are backed into a corner, and desperation can lead people to make decisions they might never have considered under different circumstances.

Once Dalia makes that decision, the tension begins to build, and I found myself increasingly anxious about what might happen next. Her well-to-do friends don’t fare much better in the common sense department. Their suggestion that they organize a baby shower for Hajira seems almost absurd when the woman doesn’t even have a home where she can keep the gifts. It is a revealing example of the distance between wanting to help someone and understanding what that person actually needs. The people around Dalia are comfortable offering gestures of generosity, but they haven’t had to confront the realities of what Hajira and Yusef are facing.

The situation also raises questions about responsibility that don’t have easy answers. Did Dalia really create the predicament she finds herself in, or are Hajira and Yusef responsible for some of the choices that bring them to her doorstep? As much as I sympathized with their circumstances, I couldn’t help thinking that they should have recognized the danger of giving up the only refuge they had, however miserable it might have been, in exchange for the uncertain promise of shelter from someone they barely knew. Showing up on the lawn of a stranger and expecting to stay there is a tremendous gamble. The couple have a child on the way, and their need for safety is understandable, but their decisions have consequences for everyone involved.

I found myself questioning Dalia’s choices from the beginning. In fact, as horrible as it sounds, while I was reading the book, I thought she should have stopped trying to find an alternative to the government housing and encouraged Hajira and Yusef to return before they lost their place in the system. The accommodations might have been inadequate, but having a roof over their heads was better than being homeless. Once they removed themselves from the arrangements available to asylum seekers, the possibility of getting back into the system became much less certain. Perhaps they would eventually find somewhere better, but without someone willing to offer them a permanent home, they had very few options. Dalia’s intervention, however well-intentioned, arguably made their situation worse.

At the same time, Brelvi doesn’t allow readers to settle comfortably into the belief that Dalia is simply a foolish woman who should have minded her own business. Hajira and Yusef want what any expectant parents want: a safe place to raise their child. They didn’t leave their home country because they were looking for an adventure, and the government accommodations offered to them are not providing the security they need. When your child’s welfare is at stake, the willingness to take risks becomes much easier to understand. Dalia recognizes their desperation, even if she doesn’t always make wise decisions in response to it.

One of the novel’s strongest points is its examination of the difference between supporting a cause in principle and accepting the consequences of supporting it in practice. Dalia’s friends want to help Hajira and Yusef, but they don’t want the couple occupying a property belonging to someone they know. They would prefer that the squatters stage their protest somewhere else, where the disruption wouldn’t affect their own lives. It is easy to advocate for refugees when someone else’s property is being used as shelter. It is another thing entirely to offer an empty family home to people who have nowhere else to go. How many people who express sympathy for refugees would actually be willing to make that offer? I suspect the answer is far fewer than would like to believe they would.


My stories and writing guidance exist because of readers like you. If my work has inspired or encouraged you, please consider sending a gift—whether it’s $1 or $1000, it brings me closer to writing full-time and keeps this creative community alive.

Give a gift today via Venmo or PayPal!


Dalia’s son makes an excellent observation about the hypocrisy of governments that help create refugee crises by destabilizing other countries and then act surprised when people flee those countries. The people displaced by political decisions and international conflicts are left to navigate systems that often fail to provide even the most basic necessities. Yet the burden of responding to their needs frequently falls on individuals and communities who may have limited resources and little authority to change the circumstances that brought those people there in the first place. Brelvi uses the conflict between these two families to examine the distance between political responsibility and personal obligation.

I also appreciated the portrayal of Dalia’s husband, Naseem. He is a patient man, and his approach to his wife’s increasingly questionable decisions made me appreciate him even more as the story progressed. He voices his concerns, but he doesn’t attempt to control her or treat her as though she is incapable of making her own choices. Even when Dalia’s actions threaten to bring trouble to their family, he respects her autonomy and allows her to decide how far she is willing to go. He treats her as an adult partner, not someone who needs to be managed. Unfortunately, watching Dalia continue down a path that I could see leading to trouble made me increasingly worried about what her decisions would cost their marriage. Even a patient husband has limits, and Naseem has just as much to lose as his wife does.

The question of what happens to their marriage becomes another source of tension. Dalia is prepared to take a stand, but Naseem has worked just as hard to build the life they enjoy in Surrey. Their home represents years of effort and the stability they want for their children. How much of that should he be expected to put at risk? Is standing beside his wife an extension of doing the right thing, or does he have an obligation to protect the family they have built? And if he chooses to distance himself from her actions, does that make him selfish, or simply someone who recognizes that compassion doesn’t require putting everyone you love in danger?

These are the questions that made The Squatters an engaging read for me. I didn’t always agree with Dalia, and there were moments when I found her decisions so frustrating that I wanted someone to explain to her why she was making a mistake. Yet I also understood what motivated her. She sees a young family in need and cannot reconcile their circumstances with the comfortable life she and her friends enjoy. Her desire to help is genuine, even when her approach sometimes seems misguided on its surface. The novel doesn’t offer an easy way to separate good intentions from bad judgment, or compassion from the consequences of acting on it.

I appreciated that the story challenged my own assumptions and forced me to reconsider my judgments as the situation unfolded. For much of the novel, I was convinced that Dalia was making one foolish decision after another, and I couldn’t understand why she kept pushing forward when the risks to her family were becoming so obvious. But by the time I reached the end, my feelings about her choices had shifted. I began to see that, in many ways, Dalia had been right all along, even if the way she went about helping Hajira and Yusef put her own family in a precarious position.

It is easy to say that people should help refugees when we aren’t the ones being asked to open our homes or put our security at risk. Dalia’s friends are willing to support the cause as long as someone else bears the burden, while Dalia is forced to confront what her convictions actually require of her. Naseem, meanwhile, has to decide how much he is willing to sacrifice alongside his wife. By the end, I found myself questioning not only Dalia’s decisions but also my own expectations of what doing the right thing should look like when the consequences are real. How far would I be willing to go to help someone? And would I have the courage to do the right thing for someone else even if it would put my own family at risk?

The Squatters by Saba Brelvi is a thought-provoking debut that puts the meaning of compassion under pressure. I spent much of the novel worrying about Dalia and her family, but the tension kept me turning the pages. More importantly, I finished the book thinking about the responsibilities we assign to others when we want to help people in need, and how quickly our convictions can change when doing so requires us to give up something of our own.

How much should one family be expected to sacrifice to help another, especially when the systems meant to protect those in need have failed them? And when doing the right thing puts your own family at risk, where do you draw the line? I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments.

An advance reader copy of this book (ARC) was provided to me by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Join the conversation

If you love books that stay with you—and enjoy thinking about them long after you’ve turned the final page—subscribe to get new literary analyses and writing tips from Write on the World!

Related Content

Now available in print and on Kindle!

Check out my latest novel, It Had to Happen, now available in print and on Kindle!

Book Summary

When Jack Utley loses his daughter just as his business is about to soar, it seems he’s traded financial gain for Callie’s life. After an encounter with a mysterious woman on the eve of Callie’s funeral, Jack wakes up to find that time has somehow rewound to the morning of Callie’s accident. Jack gets an opportunity that most grieving parents can only dream of – he saves his daughter’s life.

Now that Jack has been forced to reflect on everything he has to lose, he resolves to do better. He’s determined to spend more time at home with his family and repair the relationships that have suffered over the years while he’s been so focused on work. But as Callie’s behavior becomes increasingly bizarre, Jack realizes he has a lot more room to improve than he realized – and it might be too late to save his daughter after all.

For fans of We Need to Talk About Kevin, The Push, and Baby Teeth.

Leave a Reply