Book Reviews, Find Your Next Read

The Party in the Woods by Fiona McPhillips: a thriller about privilege, guilt, and the price of justice

The Party in the Woods by Fiona McPhillips starts with a familiar thriller setup: a group of old friends reunites years after a terrible event, hoping to make sense of what happened and perhaps put their past behind them. I’ll admit that I wasn’t sure I wanted to read another version of this story. I’ve read enough thrillers built around this premise that they’ve started to blur together, and a trope that works well the first few times can lose its appeal when authors keep returning to it. Fortunately, McPhillips has more on her mind than resurrecting old secrets and watching former friends turn against one another. What begins as a familiar mystery develops into a compelling examination of class, economic insecurity, and the choices people make when the systems around them offer little hope of a fair outcome.

Annie Fagan spent her early twenties immersed in Ireland’s illegal rave scene, playing electronic music and producing tracks as one of the country’s first female DJs. Her circle of friends included Fran Baker, a man she once believed she would end up with, and Seán, whose disappearance after a party in the woods changed the course of her life. Annie eventually left that world behind, but years later, the discovery of Seán’s body in the Dublin mountains brings the past crashing into her present. As new information emerges, the possibility that Seán died at the hands of someone who attended the party forces Annie to reconsider the people she once trusted. The mystery draws her back into a social circle she thought she had escaped, even as the life she has built since then becomes increasingly precarious.

Continue reading “The Party in the Woods by Fiona McPhillips: a thriller about privilege, guilt, and the price of justice” →
Book Reviews, Find Your Next Read

We Already Dug the Grave by Emma C. Wells: A kitschy Southern gothic thriller

I wanted to love We Already Dug the Grave. After all, I absolutely adored Emma C. Wells’ debut novel, This Girl’s a Killer, so when I saw that Wells had another book coming out, it was an automatic must-read for me. Unfortunately, while We Already Dug the Grave has plenty of the ingredients I loved in her debut, it never quite captures the same sharp wit or confidence.

We Already Dug the Grave follows estranged sisters Milly and Francis, who have spent years apart after something terrible happened in a Tennessee meadow. Milly has always been the odd one, with an ability to divine the future through tea leaves. But lately, the tea leaves have gone silent, which might seem like a blessing considering how bleak Milly’s life has become.

Continue reading “We Already Dug the Grave by Emma C. Wells: A kitschy Southern gothic thriller” →
Book Reviews, Find Your Next Read

Strange Is the Light by Sarah Maria Griffin: A dark fantasy of friendship, betrayal, and consequences

What happens when the games you invented as children turn out to be more real than you ever imagined? In Sarah Maria Griffin’s Strange Is the Light, a childhood game becomes the doorway to something ancient, dangerous, and very much alive—and the friends who created it must finally reckon with the consequences of the last time they played.

Strange Is the Light follows Daphne, Ronan, Leonie, and Finn, four childhood friends whose lives have been intertwined by a strange and somewhat magical summer friendship. Three of them live year-round on the island of Valentia, while Daphne visits only during the summers. At the center of their friendship is a game they have created together, one that begins as the kind of elaborate play-acting children do and gradually evolves into something closer to the role-playing games we know today. They create a world, invent stories and characters, and take turns building the narrative together.

Continue reading “Strange Is the Light by Sarah Maria Griffin: A dark fantasy of friendship, betrayal, and consequences” →
Book Reviews, Find Your Next Read

We Are for the Dark by Gretchen McNeil: An unsettling descent into Newfoundland horror

What if a missing-person investigation led you to an island where nothing is quite what it seems—and something ancient beneath the ground is very, very hungry? Gretchen McNeil’s We Are for the Dark, releasing September 1, 2026, takes that premise and turns it into a fast-paced supernatural horror story filled with isolated communities, religious unease, strange traditions, and a growing sense that the people arriving on the island may have made a terrible mistake.

McNeil’s novel begins with Father Shane Ryan, a recently ordained Catholic priest with an unusual past as an FBI analyst. When a priest disappears from a remote island off the coast of Newfoundland, Cardinal Jacobs calls on Ryan to investigate. At roughly the same time, Royal Newfoundland Constabulary constable Miriam Rideout becomes concerned about a frantic call she received from the missing priest. When her superiors refuse to authorize a wellness check, Miriam takes matters into her own hands and travels to the island herself. Naturally, the two eventually end up together—and neither is particularly thrilled about it.

Continue reading “We Are for the Dark by Gretchen McNeil: An unsettling descent into Newfoundland horror” →
Book Reviews, Find Your Next Read

That Night by Gillian McAllister: A gripping family thriller built on impossible choices

Gillian McAllister’s That Night is a twist-filled psychological thriller that explores family loyalty, buried secrets, and the impossible choices that follow a split-second decision. Three siblings. One terrible mistake. One secret that refuses to stay buried.

When Frannie calls her brother Joe and sister Cathy from a family vacation in Italy, she has only one thing to say: she needs help. She has struck a man with her car, and he’s dead. Together, the siblings make a split-second decision that will define the rest of their lives—they bury the body and swear never to tell another soul.

Continue reading “That Night by Gillian McAllister: A gripping family thriller built on impossible choices” →
Book Reviews, Find Your Next Read

The Women in White by Sarah Pekkanen: A compelling blend of mystery and the paranormal

Sarah Pekkanen’s The Women in White offers an engaging blend of psychological suspense, historical mystery, and paranormal intrigue. While the novel explores unsettling ethical questions about scientific experimentation, it remains an accessible page-turner with crisp prose, short chapters, and enough twists to keep readers invested until the final pages. If you’re looking for a thriller that combines a decades-old conspiracy with supernatural elements while remaining easy to read, this one is well worth adding to your list.

The novel unfolds across two timelines. In 1964, Betty is a young newlywed whose greatest ambition is simply to be a good wife. That changes when her husband, Douglas, discovers that she possesses an unusual psychic gift. Hoping to advance his academic career, he introduces Betty to Dr. Trimble, a respected university researcher studying parapsychology.

Continue reading “The Women in White by Sarah Pekkanen: A compelling blend of mystery and the paranormal” →
Book Reviews, Find Your Next Read

The Season of Sinking by Daphne Woolsoncroft: A haunting thriller about obsession, secrets, and the dangers lurking close to home

What if someone knew everything about you—but you had no idea they even existed? Daphne Woolsoncroft’s The Season of Sinking is the kind of psychological thriller that feeds on that unsettling possibility. Equal parts mystery, suspense, and creeping dread, this debut novel from the popular true crime podcaster transforms an idyllic lakeside town into a place where every glance feels suspicious and every memory hides something dangerous beneath the surface.

Set against the backdrop of a picturesque Washington community, The Season of Sinking follows Imogen Bly as she returns to her hometown of Lake Blair after her mother’s sudden death. Accompanied by her twin sister Amelia, Imogen expects a painful but straightforward task: sorting through their mother’s belongings and preparing the family home for sale. Instead, she finds herself confronted by old fears, strange occurrences, and the lingering sense that something has always been deeply wrong about the place she once called home.

Continue reading “The Season of Sinking by Daphne Woolsoncroft: A haunting thriller about obsession, secrets, and the dangers lurking close to home” →
Book Reviews, Find Your Next Read

The Neighbors Are Watching by Aggie Blum Thompson: A sharp suburban thriller about privilege, secrets, and the lies neighbors tell

The pristine lawns, expensive homes, and carefully curated lives of Bethesda’s elite hide a surprising number of ugly secrets in The Neighbors Are Watching by Aggie Blum Thompson, a twisty suburban thriller that explores what happens when privilege, obsession, and desperation collide after a murder rocks an affluent community.

Get your copy of The Neighbors Are Watching today!

Just outside Washington, D.C., the wealthy neighborhood of Eastbrook is still reeling from the unsolved murder of a nanny one year earlier. When nearly-empty-nester Caren wakes up after a graduation party with gaps in her memory and evidence suggesting she drank herself into oblivion, she suspects something much darker happened. As she begins investigating alongside a new neighbor determined to solve his best friend’s murder, long-buried secrets begin to surface—and someone is willing to kill to keep them hidden.

Continue reading “The Neighbors Are Watching by Aggie Blum Thompson: A sharp suburban thriller about privilege, secrets, and the lies neighbors tell” →
Book Reviews, Find Your Next Read

It Could Have Been Her by Lisa Jewell: A thriller that proves why she remains the genre’s best storyteller

A missing teenager, a mysterious house, and a woman forced to confront the darkest corners of her past collide in It Could Have Been Her by Lisa Jewell, a gripping and emotionally rich thriller that reminds me exactly why she remains my favorite author working in the genre today. Releasing June 23, 2026, this latest novel begins with a seemingly simple mystery involving a lost dog before spiraling into something far more layered, unsettling, and deeply personal.

Get your copy of It Could Have Been Her today!

Thriller novels often follow familiar patterns. There’s a reason readers keep coming back to them. Like a favorite comfort food, the genre offers recognizable tropes, satisfying twists, and reliable entertainment. There is absolutely nothing wrong with that. Not every book needs to reinvent literature, and sometimes readers simply want an engaging story that delivers exactly what it promises.

But Lisa Jewell has never been that kind of writer.

Continue reading “It Could Have Been Her by Lisa Jewell: A thriller that proves why she remains the genre’s best storyteller” →
Book Reviews, Find Your Next Read

Dark Sisters by Kristi DeMeester: A fierce, feminist horror that burns with rage—though not always with realism

Kristi DeMeester’s Dark Sisters (releasing December 9, 2025) takes on patriarchal power, religious hypocrisy, and generational trauma with fire, blood, and no small dose of feminine fury—but sometimes the blaze feels more like stage lighting than wildfire. It’s the kind of novel that makes you want to light a match and watch the patriarchy burn. Part historical fiction, part supernatural horror, and part feminist manifesto, this story spans centuries and three women bound by a curse born of desperation and defiance.

Get your copy of Dark Sisters from my independent online bookstore today!

Anne Bolton, accused of witchcraft in the 1700s, bargains with darkness to survive. Mary Shephard, the obedient 1950s housewife, discovers forbidden love with a woman named Sharon. And Camilla Burson, a modern preacher’s daughter, rebels against both her father and the system he represents.

Continue reading “Dark Sisters by Kristi DeMeester: A fierce, feminist horror that burns with rage—though not always with realism” →