Book Reviews, Find Your Next Read

That Night by Gillian McAllister: A gripping family thriller built on impossible choices

Gillian McAllister’s That Night is a twist-filled psychological thriller that explores family loyalty, buried secrets, and the impossible choices that follow a split-second decision. Three siblings. One terrible mistake. One secret that refuses to stay buried.

When Frannie calls her brother Joe and sister Cathy from a family vacation in Italy, she has only one thing to say: she needs help. She has struck a man with her car, and he’s dead. Together, the siblings make a split-second decision that will define the rest of their lives—they bury the body and swear never to tell another soul.

Of course, secrets like that rarely stay buried. As police begin asking questions, the siblings’ carefully constructed story starts to unravel. Distrust creeps into relationships that once seemed unbreakable, and everyone begins wondering whether they’re hearing the whole truth about what really happened that night.

That Night is exactly the kind of thriller I enjoy reading during the summer. It’s well written, fast-paced, and consistently keeps readers guessing about what’s really happening. The suspense isn’t built around elaborate conspiracies or over-the-top action sequences. Instead, Gillian McAllister creates tension by placing ordinary people in an extraordinary situation and allowing their increasingly desperate decisions to compound.

The novel continually shifts your assumptions about the characters and their motivations. Every time I thought I had a handle on where the story was heading, another revelation forced me to reconsider what I’d already read. That’s exactly what I want from a thriller.

While this isn’t a novel that dives deeply into philosophical or literary themes, I don’t think it’s trying to be. Its goal is to entertain, and it succeeds remarkably well. There is, however, an interesting thread running beneath the suspense about the nature of family. When push comes to shove, who deserves your loyalty: the family you were born into or the family you’ve chosen as an adult?

Years before the events of the novel, Joe, Cathy, and Frannie lost their youngest sibling when she was only eight years old. Their parents never truly recovered from that devastating loss, forcing the surviving siblings to become far more dependent on one another than they otherwise might have been. Frannie effectively becomes the family’s youngest child after the tragedy, while Joe naturally steps into a patriarchal role.


My stories and writing guidance exist because of readers like you. If my work has inspired or encouraged you, please consider sending a gift—whether it’s $1 or $1000, it brings me closer to writing full-time and keeps this creative community alive.

Give a gift today via Venmo or PayPal!


That dynamic is fascinating because Joe’s protectiveness often slips into toxic masculinity. He genuinely loves his sisters and is capable of remarkable tenderness toward them, yet his instinct to control situations frequently creates new problems rather than solving existing ones.

Throughout the novel, these siblings repeatedly choose one another above everyone else, including spouses and partners. Their loyalty is admirable, but it’s also deeply complicated. As often happens in a group of three, two siblings naturally become closer at different points, leaving the third feeling isolated. McAllister uses that dynamic to excellent effect. As doubts begin creeping into the siblings’ minds, it becomes increasingly clear that not everyone is telling the whole truth. The sibling left on the outside begins to wonder whether the other two might ultimately sacrifice her to save themselves.

Adding to the tension is the simple fact that none of them can seem to keep their mouths shut. They agree to bury the body, return home, and move on with their lives, yet each eventually shares pieces of the secret with someone outside their circle. There’s an old saying that two people can keep a secret—but only if one of them is dead. What happens when three people share a devastating secret and then each begins expanding the circle of people who know? You’ll have to read That Night to find out.

That Night is an engaging, twist-filled thriller that delivers exactly what it promises: an addictive mystery, compelling family drama, and plenty of surprising turns along the way. While it doesn’t aim for profound thematic depth, its exploration of sibling loyalty gives the story more emotional weight than many thrillers in the genre.

If you’re looking for a suspense novel that will keep you turning pages while making you question every character’s version of the truth, this is an easy recommendation.

If you enjoyed the family secrets and escalating lies in That Night, you might also enjoy Wrong Place Wrong Time by Gillian McAllister, The Last Flight by Julie Clark, Rock Paper Scissors by Alice Feeney, and Getting Away With Murder by Shari Lapena.

What would you do to protect the people you love? Let me know your thoughts in the comments!

An advance reader copy of this book (ARC) was provided to me by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Join the conversation

If you love books that stay with you—and enjoy thinking about them long after you’ve turned the final page—subscribe to get new literary analyses and writing tips from Write on the World!

Related Content

Now available in print and on Kindle!

Check out my latest novel, It Had to Happen, now available in print and on Kindle!

Book Summary

When Jack Utley loses his daughter just as his business is about to soar, it seems he’s traded financial gain for Callie’s life. After an encounter with a mysterious woman on the eve of Callie’s funeral, Jack wakes up to find that time has somehow rewound to the morning of Callie’s accident. Jack gets an opportunity that most grieving parents can only dream of – he saves his daughter’s life.

Now that Jack has been forced to reflect on everything he has to lose, he resolves to do better. He’s determined to spend more time at home with his family and repair the relationships that have suffered over the years while he’s been so focused on work. But as Callie’s behavior becomes increasingly bizarre, Jack realizes he has a lot more room to improve than he realized – and it might be too late to save his daughter after all.

For fans of We Need to Talk About Kevin, The Push, and Baby Teeth.

Leave a Reply