City of Widows by Nadia Hashimi: A breathtaking portrait of survival under the Taliban

There are novels that entertain, and then there are novels that demand to be witnessed. City of Widows by Nadia Hashimi is firmly in the latter category—a sweeping, emotionally devastating, and ultimately hopeful story that puts human faces on the headlines many of us have long since stopped reading.

Nadia Hashimi tells an ambitious story that spans decades of Afghan history while remaining deeply rooted in the lives of individual women. The result is an absolutely riveting novel that is as suspenseful as it is heartbreaking. Despite its large cast of characters, dual timelines, and enormous historical scope, the story remains remarkably cohesive. Every thread contributes to a larger portrait of women fighting to preserve not only their lives, but also their dignity, their families, and their sense of self.

One of the novel’s greatest strengths is its structure. The story unfolds across two timelines, contrasting life during the years of the American occupation with the terrifying days surrounding the Taliban’s return to power in 2021. The comparison is fascinating because Hashimi refuses to oversimplify either period. Life for Afghan women is never portrayed as easy. Both systems are deeply patriarchal, and both place enormous limitations on women’s autonomy. The crucial distinction lies in who controls those limitations.

During the years of the American occupation, the amount of freedom available to a woman often depends on her family. Afghan society contains a broad spectrum of beliefs. Some families refuse to let women leave the family compound except under the strictest supervision, expecting them to spend their lives cooking, cleaning, and caring for relatives. Others encourage their daughters to pursue education, careers, journalism, medicine, law, and even military service. Yet even in these more progressive households, reputation remains everything. Rumors surrounding one woman can tarnish an entire family’s standing within the community.

Under Taliban rule, however, those family choices largely disappear. The state itself becomes determined to strip women of their freedoms regardless of what their own families might want for them. Watching these women realize exactly what is about to happen—and knowing that there is almost nowhere left to run—creates extraordinary tension throughout the novel.

At the center of the story is Marjan, whose life illustrates both the brutality and resilience found throughout the novel. Readers familiar with Hashimi’s earlier work will recognize that Marjan was once known as Rahima, a bacha posh—a girl raised as a boy. Her family adopted this tradition because they had no sons, allowing Rahima to enjoy freedoms typically reserved for boys while also shielding her sisters from some of the social stigma attached to families without male children. That freedom ends abruptly when, at just thirteen years old, she is married to a violent warlord.

Although the novel references the sexual violence and abuse she endures throughout the marriage, Hashimi wisely chooses not to depict those assaults on the page. Instead, the emotional and psychological consequences of that abuse speak for themselves, making Marjan’s suffering no less devastating while allowing the story to remain focused on her resilience rather than her victimization.

What makes Marjan especially compelling is the way the women around her repeatedly describe her as a warrior. They marvel at her ability to survive horrors that would have broken many people. Yet the novel raises an intriguing question without ever fully answering it. Is Marjan naturally extraordinary? Or does her childhood as a bacha posh fundamentally shape the person she becomes?

Having spent her early years being treated as a boy, Marjan develops a sense of personal agency that many girls in her society are never permitted to experience. She grows up believing—at least for a time—that she has the right to move through the world freely.

That difference becomes striking when comparing her to her sisters. Marjan and two of her sisters are married off simultaneously. One later finds her husband’s cruelty so unbearable that she ultimately douses herself with gasoline and sets herself on fire to escape. Marjan, by contrast, eventually reaches a moment when she simply decides to leave. She just—walks out.

That act of defiance feels almost unimaginable within the world Hashimi has constructed, suggesting that the confidence instilled during Marjan’s childhood may have become one of the greatest advantages she ever possessed.

One of the novel’s most thought-provoking themes is privilege—not privilege in the way many Western readers typically think about it, but the subtle advantages that can exist even within profoundly oppressive societies. Marjan unquestionably suffers throughout her life. Yet compared to many of the women around her, she possesses advantages others never receive.

---

---

Being raised as a boy gives her confidence, practical experience, and a sense of independence. Throughout her life, she also repeatedly finds herself connected to people willing to help her survive. After escaping her husband, she finds refuge in a women’s shelter, where she gives birth to her daughter, Hawa. Later she moves into transitional housing before economic realities force another impossible decision: accepting work that provides room and board but prohibits children.

Unable to keep Hawa with her, Marjan places her daughter in an orphanage while working toward a future where they can finally build a home together. Although the separation is heartbreaking, it also grants Hawa opportunities that many Afghan girls never receive. The orphanage provides her with an excellent education, one that likely would have been out of reach had she remained at home with her mother. Later, Hawa attends a music school, where she not only continues her education but also gains access to musical instruction and instruments—opportunities that become almost unimaginable once the Taliban returns to power.

Like Marjan’s unusual upbringing as a bacha posh, Hawa’s path demonstrates that privilege can emerge in unexpected ways, even amid profound hardship. These advantages never erase the suffering both mother and daughter endure, but they help explain how each is able to imagine possibilities beyond the narrow roles society expects women to occupy. Hashimi never presents these fortunate encounters as easy solutions. Instead, they highlight how survival often depends on timing, community, and chance just as much as personal courage.

The novel’s later timeline becomes increasingly suspenseful as Kabul falls. Marjan now serves in the Afghan Army, watching helplessly as province after province collapses under Taliban control. Former government officials, soldiers, journalists, translators, and anyone associated with the Americans grow increasingly desperate to escape before the final withdrawal.

Hashimi captures the chaos surrounding Kabul’s airport with remarkable intensity. Marjan repeatedly attempts to gain the attention of American soldiers guarding the gates, hoping to secure passage for herself and Hawa before time runs out.

As if the Taliban were not dangerous enough, Marjan also learns that the abusive husband she escaped more than a decade earlier has discovered she is alive—and is searching for her. The overlapping threats create relentless momentum during the novel’s second half.

The novel’s title ultimately refers to one of its most memorable settings. The City of Widows is a small settlement on the outskirts of Kabul where women have created something extraordinary: a community governed by women themselves. It exists on the margins of society, tolerated only because carefully paid bribes allow the settlement to continue. No one knows how long such a place can survive under Taliban rule.

Life there is far from easy. The women work tirelessly to support their families. Some must beg to survive. Resources remain scarce. Yet for perhaps the first time in the novel, readers glimpse a community where women return home to houses they control, make decisions about their own lives, and belong only to themselves. Yes, they still exist within a patriarchal society and must effectively pay for the privilege of being left alone. But within their own community, they have carved out a measure of independence that stands in stark contrast to the world beyond its borders.

The City of Widows becomes a powerful symbol—not of perfect freedom, but of the remarkable ways women continue creating spaces for autonomy even within systems designed to deny it.

City of Widows is an exceptional novel that succeeds on every level. It is historically illuminating without becoming didactic, emotionally gripping without becoming manipulative, and filled with characters who feel fully human rather than symbolic. Hashimi refuses to reduce Afghan women to victims. Instead, she presents them as soldiers, journalists, mothers, daughters, survivors, and leaders—women making impossible decisions under impossible circumstances while refusing to surrender their humanity.

This is not an easy read. The novel deals with child marriage, domestic abuse, war, political persecution, and the ever-present threat of sexual violence, though the sexual assaults themselves occur off the page. It is also a profoundly compassionate novel about endurance, community, and hope.

Perhaps what stayed with me most is the novel’s nuanced examination of privilege. Marjan’s childhood as a bacha posh, Hawa’s education in the orphanage and music school, and the women of the City of Widows all illustrate that even within profoundly oppressive systems, opportunity is rarely distributed equally. Small advantages—whether they come through family, education, timing, or simple chance—can become life-changing. Rather than diminishing anyone’s suffering, these differences remind us how complex survival really is.

Few novels manage to be both epic in scope and intensely personal. City of Widows accomplishes exactly that, making it one of the most memorable historical novels of the year. Have you read City of Widows, or are you planning to pick it up when it releases? I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments.

An advance reader copy of this book (ARC) was provided to me by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Join the conversation

If you love books that stay with you—and enjoy thinking about them long after you’ve turned the final page—subscribe to get new literary analyses and writing tips from Write on the World!

Related Content

• When choosing one career means rejecting another (She Writes)
• In conversation with author Nadia Hashimi (Medium – Coffee and Conversations)
• An Afghan author on losing her homeland (NPR)
• A non-Western representation of the third world women in Nadia Hashimi’s A House without Windows (AWEJ for Translation & Literary Studies)

Now available in print and on Kindle!

Now that Jack has been forced to reflect on everything he has to lose, he resolves to do better. He’s determined to spend more time at home with his family and repair the relationships that have suffered over the years while he’s been so focused on work. But as Callie’s behavior becomes increasingly bizarre, Jack realizes he has a lot more room to improve than he realized – and it might be too late to save his daughter after all.

For fans of We Need to Talk About Kevin, The Push, and Baby Teeth.