Writers on Writing

It Had to Happen: Time, grief, and the illusion of control

It Had to Happen begins with a devastating, almost clean fracture in a man’s life: Jack Utley loses his daughter just as his business is finally about to take off. In that moment, success and loss become entangled in a way that feels almost transactional—like one has been traded for the other. Jack is left doing what many grieving parents do in fiction and in life: trying to assign meaning to something that refuses to make sense. Then the story shifts into something far less predictable.

On the eve of his daughter Callie’s funeral, Jack encounters a mysterious woman. After that meeting, he wakes to find that time has somehow rewound itself to the morning of the accident. Suddenly, he is given what grief never allows in reality: a second chance. He saves his daughter’s life. But the novel is not interested in treating that as a simple gift.

From the beginning, Jack believes this rewind is an opportunity to correct everything—not just the accident, but the life that led up to it. He resolves to change: to be more present, to step back from work, to repair the emotional gaps that have formed between him and his family. In his mind, the problem has always been imbalance. Too much work. Too little home. Too little attention to what mattered. And at first, it seems like that diagnosis might be enough.

But It Had to Happen is ultimately less interested in the miracle itself than in what people do with the idea of a miracle. As Jack attempts to rebuild his family life, Callie begins to behave in ways that don’t align with the version of her he has always carried in his mind. The more time he spends “fixing” things, the more unstable his understanding of his own home becomes. What he believed he knew about his daughter, his wife, and his son starts to shift in uncomfortable ways. The unsettling question at the center of the novel is not just what happens if you get a second chance but what if your first version of reality was already incomplete?

Jack has always seen himself as a successful provider, a man who has built a comfortable life for his family. That identity comes with assumptions: that effort equals care, that financial provision substitutes for emotional presence, and that his internal image of a “perfect family” corresponds to what actually exists in his home. The rewind disrupts that certainty. It forces him into proximity with the parts of his life he has previously delegated, ignored, or simplified.

His wife, in particular, becomes more than a background presence in this revised timeline. The dynamic between them exposes long-standing fractures in how responsibility, resentment, and expectation have been distributed. Jack has spent years believing he is the stabilizing force, while everything at home is managed, softened, or absorbed by someone else. The story slowly undermines that belief.


My stories and writing guidance exist because of readers like you. If my work has inspired or encouraged you, please consider sending a gift—whether it’s $1 or $1000, it brings me closer to writing full-time and keeps this creative community alive.

Give a gift today via Venmo or PayPal!


The same is true for his children. Callie is no longer simply the idealized daughter whose loss motivates the entire emotional engine of the plot. She becomes something more complex—less fixed, less symbolic, and more human in ways that Jack is not prepared to understand. And that shift is where the tension of the novel truly begins to build.

What I enjoyed most in writing this story was placing Jack in the position so many people fantasize about during grief: the ability to go back and do it differently. On the surface, it looks like redemption. But structurally, it becomes something more unsettling. A second chance does not automatically produce clarity. Instead, it reveals how much of Jack’s earlier certainty was built on assumption rather than understanding.

There is also an intentional discomfort in how Jack interprets the world around him. He sees himself as rational, successful, and largely fair-minded, but the rewind exposes the gap between how he believes things function and how they actually function. His frustrations with his wife, his assumptions about his son, and even his idealization of Callie begin to read differently under pressure. The story asks whether his original tragedy was an isolated moment—or the endpoint of a much longer chain of misread signals and avoided responsibilities.

At its core, It Had to Happen is about control—who thinks they have it, who actually does, and what happens when that illusion is stripped away. It is also about the stories people tell themselves to survive the roles they occupy inside a family, especially when those roles become easier to perform than to question. Jack believes he is trying to save his daughter. The novel keeps asking whether he is also trying to save the version of himself that existed before everything broke. And those two goals may not be compatible.

If you’ve read the novel, I’d love to hear your thoughts on Jack’s choices once he gets the chance to change things. Does he actually improve the situation—or just uncover problems that were already there? Let me know in the comments.

This post is part of a series where I pull back the curtain on the novels I’ve written, beginning with Valley of the Bees, a dystopian YA novel about survival, freedom, and growing up in a near-future world where girls have little control over their own lives. Each post looks at how a story took shape and what it taught me about finishing the work I start. Learn about this book and others from Elderfly Press today!

Join the conversation

If you love books that stay with you—and enjoy thinking about them long after you’ve turned the final page—subscribe to get new literary analyses and writing tips from Write on the World!

Now available in print and on Kindle!

Check out my latest novel, It Had to Happen, now available in print and on Kindle!

Book Summary

When Jack Utley loses his daughter just as his business is about to soar, it seems he’s traded financial gain for Callie’s life. After an encounter with a mysterious woman on the eve of Callie’s funeral, Jack wakes up to find that time has somehow rewound to the morning of Callie’s accident. Jack gets an opportunity that most grieving parents can only dream of – he saves his daughter’s life.

Now that Jack has been forced to reflect on everything he has to lose, he resolves to do better. He’s determined to spend more time at home with his family and repair the relationships that have suffered over the years while he’s been so focused on work. But as Callie’s behavior becomes increasingly bizarre, Jack realizes he has a lot more room to improve than he realized – and it might be too late to save his daughter after all.

For fans of We Need to Talk About Kevin, The Push, and Baby Teeth.

Leave a Reply