The Witch of Willow Sound is a haunting tale of memory, superstition, and the danger of silence

If you lived beneath a rock that might crush you at any moment, would you believe in witches? In The Witch of Willow Sound, debut author Vanessa F. Penney weaves a chilling and fast-paced gothic tale that blends feminist themes with East Coast folklore, offering a story that’s as unsettling as it is poignant. When Fade returns to the shadowy forests of Willow Sound, Nova Scotia, in search of her missing aunt Madeline, she finds only a rotting cottage and a community eager to assign blame. The villagers of nearby Grand Tea have always called Madeline a witch—but now, as misfortunes pile up and a hurricane approaches, their fear is turning violent.

The worldbuilding in this novel is both original and deeply atmospheric. At the heart of Grand Tea’s folklore and fear is a massive rock perched above the town, a looming presence that could fall at any moment. You can feel the weight of it as you read—how its threat presses down on the villagers, shaping their beliefs, their behaviors, even their cruelty. The psychological tension it creates is masterful. It makes perfect, eerie sense that a place so precariously positioned would invent scapegoats and spin stories about curses and witches. The mob mentality that develops is reminiscent of The Crucible, complete with paranoia and projection.

Yet, for all the novel’s darkness, there is unexpected warmth—especially in the friendship between Fade and the town’s archivist. Both social outsiders, their bond feels real and necessary. Fade, hardened by years of distance and distrust, surprises even herself by opening up to this odd, endearing man who jumps at the chance to help her. Their connection is one of the emotional cores of the book and offers a welcome glimmer of hope.

At its heart, this is a story about family and the deep wounds left by silence. Fade’s estrangement from Madeline isn’t hers by choice—it’s the result of a falling-out between her aunt and mother that spiraled into decades of lost time. Now, faced with Madeline’s disappearance, Fade has to confront not only a terrifying mystery, but her own regrets. Penney handles these emotional threads with care, reminding us how quickly opportunities can slip away when pride, pain, or miscommunication go unspoken.

The Witch of Willow Sound is perfect for readers who love modern gothic stories, feminist reimaginings of folklore, and atmospheric mysteries with emotional depth. It’s a gripping reminder of how superstition and fear can shape entire communities—and how easy it is to lose those we love when we don’t take the time to listen.

What do you think the rock in Grand Tea symbolizes? How does it reflect the choices—or inaction—of the people living under it?

An advance reader copy of this book (ARC) was provided to me by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Related Content

• The Witch of Willow Sound Book Club Guide (ECW Press)
• Indie Presses: To Each Their Own Lane (Library Journal)
• Review: The Witch of Willow Sound – Vanessa F. Penney (The Fiction Fox)
• The Witch of Willow Sound by Vanessa F. Penney- ARC- REVIEW (The Starry Library)

Now available in print and on Kindle!

Now that Jack has been forced to reflect on everything he has to lose, he resolves to do better. He’s determined to spend more time at home with his family and repair the relationships that have suffered over the years while he’s been so focused on work. But as Callie’s behavior becomes increasingly bizarre, Jack realizes he has a lot more room to improve than he realized – and it might be too late to save his daughter after all.

For fans of We Need to Talk About Kevin, The Push, and Baby Teeth.