Book Review: The False Flat by Melissa R. Collings

Sometimes, life’s most pivotal moments happen when you least expect them—like a chance encounter over a box of Cap’n Crunch cereal. In Melissa Collings’ The False Flat, protagonist Penelope Auberge reminds us that even the messiest lives can be reshaped with courage, a little humor, and the right people by your side.

Pen is at her breaking point: juggling an overbearing mother, a toxic relationship with her married boyfriend, and a finance career where her efforts are overshadowed by her male colleagues. Instead of sinking under the weight of it all, she does something most of us only dream of: she uproots her life, leaving Minnesota for Tennessee to start fresh. Determined to open her own financial business and build a life she can truly call her own, Pen sets off for Nashville with a plan to reinvent herself. But she soon learns that even the best-laid plans can’t erase the past.

The heart of The False Flat lies in the relationships Pen forms in her new city, particularly with siblings Deanna and Grant. Pen’s first meeting with Deanna, sparked by a shared craving for cereal, is one of the most charming moments in the book. It’s a reminder that real-life connections can happen anywhere, even over the most mundane things—as long as you’re open to them. Their friendship grows slowly, giving Pen the emotional grounding she needs to confront her social anxieties and trust again.

And then there’s Grant. Joining his cycling group was supposed to be a step toward fitness and community, not the beginning of a budding romance. But as sparks fly, Pen finds herself wrestling with her feelings, afraid of opening up only to be hurt again. Her journey—from resisting Grant’s charm to embracing the possibility of love—is as heartwarming as it is relatable.

Of course, Pen’s past doesn’t simply vanish when she crosses state lines. The challenges she faces in Tennessee—from lingering self-doubt to unresolved issues with her mother and ex—underscore an essential truth: moving forward isn’t just about physical distance but emotional growth.

What I found most compelling about The False Flat is its portrayal of female friendship. Deanna’s support and patience are a powerful counterbalance to Pen’s hesitancy, showing how transformative a true friendship can be. Their bond isn’t instant but grows organically, with moments of vulnerability and mutual care. It made me wonder: is it really so hard to meet people like this in real life, or do we just need to be open to unexpected connections? Perhaps the next time I’m eyeing a box of cereal, I’ll strike up a conversation.

I first encountered Melissa Collings at the Louisville Book Festival, where she was a featured author. I was thrilled when she later agreed to an interview for my blog. Reading The False Flat felt like getting to know Melissa—her knack for crafting authentic, relatable characters shines throughout the book.

In the end, The False Flat is about more than starting over; it’s about discovering who you truly are and finding the courage to live that truth. For anyone who’s ever dreamed of leaving their baggage behind and starting anew, Pen’s journey will inspire you to think, “Why not me?”

Have you read The False Flat or had your own experience of reinvention? I’d love to hear your thoughts! Share in the comments below.

Related Content

• Will you be in my next book? (Melissa Collings’ Blog)
• The False Flat – Book Review (Reader’s Favorite)
• Melissa Collings, author of The False Flat, in conversation (Parnassus Books)
• Summer’s One Must Read Book 2024 (Reading Ladies Book Club)
• Discussion with Melissa R. Collings: Author on WriterFest Podcast with Ami McConnell

Now available in print and on Kindle!

Now that Jack has been forced to reflect on everything he has to lose, he resolves to do better. He’s determined to spend more time at home with his family and repair the relationships that have suffered over the years while he’s been so focused on work. But as Callie’s behavior becomes increasingly bizarre, Jack realizes he has a lot more room to improve than he realized – and it might be too late to save his daughter after all.

For fans of We Need to Talk About Kevin, The Push, and Baby Teeth.