Such Sheltered Lives by Alyssa Sheinmel: Celebrity rehab, buried secrets, and a thriller that finds its footing late

Such Sheltered Lives by Alyssa Sheinmel opens inside an ultra-exclusive Hamptons rehab center built on discretion, money, and the promise that no one on the outside will ever find out what happens within its gates. From the opening pages, we know a body will be found on a nearby beach—and that inevitability hangs over Rush’s Recovery like a threat the staff can’t quite contain.

I’ll be honest: this book gets off to a rough start. The early writing feels tentative and occasionally amateurish, and there are factual errors that pulled me sharply out of the story. One in particular made me stop and reread in disbelief: a character’s academic background is described in a way that suggests someone earned—or was earning—a PhD through night classes at a community college. That’s not a minor slip in phrasing; it’s a fundamental misunderstanding of how higher education works. No one is getting a doctorate that way. Errors like this made me question the author’s lived experience and research, and they chipped away at my trust in the narrative early on.

I very nearly DNFed the book. In fact, under normal circumstances, I probably would have. But I’d already abandoned several poorly executed novels in a row and was falling behind on reviews for my blog—and this book, for all its flaws, was at least trying to do something interesting. So I stuck with it. I’m glad I did.

As the story unfolds, the writing improves noticeably. The pacing smooths out, the character work deepens, and the novel starts to feel more confident in what it wants to be. I had the distinct impression that Sheinmel was getting to know her characters as she wrote them—and that what’s missing is a strong revision pass to bring the earlier chapters into alignment with what she ultimately learns about them by the end. The foundation is there; it just isn’t consistently supported from page one.

Structurally, the book is one of Sheinmel’s strongest efforts. The first-person perspectives of the three rehab “guests”—a disgraced British aristocrat, the daughter of a ’90s rock legend, and a pop star attempting to disappear after a tabloid scandal—are interspersed with brief chapters from people connected to a mysterious death. We hear from the elderly woman who finds the body on the beach, from the coroner who performs the autopsy, and from others tangentially tied to the event. While we know early on that someone dies, Sheinmel maintains suspense by keeping us guessing whether the death involves one of the current guests or relates to a tragedy from the past.

---

---

By the final third of the novel, my judgment shifted from persistent eye-rolling to genuine appreciation. There is real, raw talent here—even if it isn’t fully realized yet. What began as a two-star read grew into something closer to a solid 3.5 by the end. With a sharper editorial eye—one willing to catch factual errors early, tighten the opening chapters, and push the thematic depth further—this could easily have landed at four stars. To reach five would require a stronger exploration of what fame, secrecy, and recovery actually cost the people trapped inside systems like Rush’s Recovery.

Readers who enjoyed Made You Look by Tanya Grant—with its glossy surface, morally compromised characters, and unsettling look at wealth and secrecy—will likely find a similar appeal here, particularly once Such Sheltered Lives settles into its rhythm.

Such Sheltered Lives isn’t a must-read, but it is an interesting one, especially for readers drawn to insular settings, celebrity culture, and slow-burn psychological suspense. More importantly, Alyssa Sheinmel feels like an author to watch. If her craft continues to evolve—and if future books are paired with a more rigorous editor—her next novel could be something genuinely special.

Have you read Such Sheltered Lives or another Alyssa Sheinmel novel? I’d love to hear what worked—or didn’t—for you in the comments.

An advance reader copy of this book (ARC) was provided to me by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Related Content

• An author joins us: Alyssa Sheinmel of The Lucky Kind (Random Acts of Reading)
• Guest post – Why I wrote Faceless by Alyssa Sheinmel (Tales Point Hollow Book Club)
• Interview with Alyssa Sheinmel, author of R.I.P. Eliza Hart (Germ Magazine)
• TWO MINUTES WITH … Faceless author Alyssa Sheinmel (Chicken House Books)

Now available in print and on Kindle!

Now that Jack has been forced to reflect on everything he has to lose, he resolves to do better. He’s determined to spend more time at home with his family and repair the relationships that have suffered over the years while he’s been so focused on work. But as Callie’s behavior becomes increasingly bizarre, Jack realizes he has a lot more room to improve than he realized – and it might be too late to save his daughter after all.

For fans of We Need to Talk About Kevin, The Push, and Baby Teeth.