Book Review: Darling Girls by Sally Hepworth

Sally Hepworth’s Darling Girls is a psychological thriller that delves into the complexities of sisterhood, trauma, and the haunting shadows of a past that refuses to stay buried. At the heart of the story are Jessica, Norah, and Alicia—three women whose childhoods were marred by tragedy and shaped by the unpredictable and controlling presence of their foster mother, Miss Fairchild.

A Story of Secrets and Survival

From the outside, Jessica, Norah, and Alicia had everything a child in foster care could wish for—a safe, idyllic home on a sprawling estate, and the promise of a second chance at happiness. Miss Fairchild, their foster mother, was seen as a saint by the outside world, offering them a haven in the wake of their traumatic pasts. However, the truth of their upbringing was far from idyllic. Miss Fairchild’s “love” was superficial and performed only for others to see.

For the first girl to be fostered, Jessica, the love was conditional—she was adored when she was the only child, but once Norah and Alicia entered the picture, that affection quickly turned cold. Jessica was relegated to a position of neglect, while Miss Fairchild’s public affection for her foster children remained just that—public, for appearances’ sake. Behind closed doors, the girls were subjected to a rigid, controlling environment where affection was scarce and only ever offered when others were watching.

Darling Girls opens with the discovery of a body buried beneath the floorboards of their childhood home, forcing the estranged sisters to confront their buried memories. As the investigation into the death unfolds, the question looms: was Miss Fairchild an abuser, or was she a victim herself—someone shaped by her own demons, who sought to mold the girls into reflections of her own twisted version of “family”? Hepworth expertly balances the ambiguity of Miss Fairchild’s character, leaving readers questioning her true nature up until the final pages.

Foster Care and the Unheard Voices of Children

Beyond the mystery at the core of Darling Girls, Hepworth explores a more profound and troubling theme—the systemic failures of the foster care system, and the silencing of vulnerable children. The sisters’ stories are filled with moments where they were overlooked or dismissed when they attempted to express their pain, and even when they were being harmed. Their fears and struggles were brushed aside by social workers, family members, and society at large.

Hepworth’s portrayal of Miss Fairchild is crucial in illustrating how children in foster care are often neglected in ways that are not just emotional, but institutional. As the girls’ stories unfold, it becomes clear that they were trapped in a system that failed to hear their cries for help. In many ways, Miss Fairchild’s abuse of power echoes the way the system itself turned a blind eye to their suffering. The novel is particularly resonant in its portrayal of how, as children, they lacked the agency to fully understand or articulate their trauma, and how they were expected to accept a version of “family” that was both unhealthy and dangerous.

The Dark Side of Sisterhood

The bond between Jessica, Norah, and Alicia is one of the novel’s most compelling aspects. Their shared history—both the love they received from Miss Fairchild and the ways they suffered under her—binds them together, even when they have drifted apart as adults. Darling Girls explores how trauma manifests in adulthood, and how the scars of the past shape their present relationships, sometimes in subtle and unexpected ways. Their interactions are colored by years of unsaid things, and the mystery surrounding Miss Fairchild’s true nature makes it even harder for them to trust each other fully.

The question of what they owe each other as sisters—whether to protect one another, or to reveal long-hidden truths—adds another layer of tension and intrigue. Hepworth masterfully weaves themes of loyalty, betrayal, and the weight of secrets into the narrative, making it clear that even the deepest familial bonds are often fraught with complexity and unresolved pain.

The Mystery of Miss Fairchild

As the investigation into the body under the house progresses, the question of Miss Fairchild’s true nature becomes more urgent. Is she a cold, calculating abuser who preyed on vulnerable children for her own sadistic pleasure? Or was she, too, a victim—someone broken by her own tragic past, who turned to controlling others in a misguided attempt to heal her own wounds? The novel doesn’t provide easy answers, but it raises thought-provoking questions about the cycles of abuse, victimhood, and power.

Throughout the novel, Miss Fairchild remains a figure shrouded in mystery. While the evidence points toward her cruelty, Hepworth invites the reader to consider whether Miss Fairchild was simply an abuser, or if she was a product of her own suffering, trapped in a cycle of harm that she couldn’t break. By the end of the story, the truth about Miss Fairchild is revealed—but whether she was merely a perpetrator or also a victim in her own right is something that will stay with readers long after the final page.

Conclusion: A Thrilling, Thought-Provoking Read

Darling Girls is a compelling read that keeps you on the edge of your seat, while also offering a nuanced examination of trauma, memory, and the fragility of the foster care system. Sally Hepworth once again proves herself a master of domestic thrillers, with a story that is both emotionally resonant and expertly paced. The way she explores the psychological effects of abuse—how it twists the minds of both victims and perpetrators—adds a richness to the mystery that will stay with readers long after the book is closed.

If you’re looking for a gripping, emotional thriller that tackles tough subjects with empathy and suspense, Darling Girls is the unforgettable read for you!

More Books by This Author

Shop these and other Sally Hepworth titles now.

Related Content

• Book Review (Portobello Book Blog)
• Sally Hepworth on ‘The Lies That Bind’ in ‘The Good Sister’ (The Girlfriend)
• The Soulmate (spoilers and ending explained) | Sally Hepworth (PhDiva)
• Darling Girls Book Review (Seattle Book Mama)
• Darling Girls Book Review (Leah’s Books)

Now available in print and on Kindle!

Now that Jack has been forced to reflect on everything he has to lose, he resolves to do better. He’s determined to spend more time at home with his family and repair the relationships that have suffered over the years while he’s been so focused on work. But as Callie’s behavior becomes increasingly bizarre, Jack realizes he has a lot more room to improve than he realized – and it might be too late to save his daughter after all.

For fans of We Need to Talk About Kevin, The Push, and Baby Teeth.